It's not unusual for those who see a therapist to feel that their therapy relationship means something more. Such a relationship is intimate in many ways, and it can be easy to mistake therapeutic relationships for actual friendship. While most would agree that sexual relationships are not ethical when it comes to a mental health professional, many may wonder whether a friendship growing out of a relationship with your therapist would be problematic. Let's take a closer look at this scenario.
The Therapeutic Relationship
First, let's examine the concept of a therapeutic alliance. A therapeutic relationship is a unique and intimate connection between a therapist and client, built on trust, confidentiality, and a power imbalance.
The therapist’s role is to provide a safe and non-judgmental space for the client to explore their thoughts, feelings, and experiences. The therapeutic relationship is meant to be a one-sided connection, where the therapist maintains professional boundaries and the client shares personal details. This relationship is essential for effective therapy, but it can also create challenges for forming a friendship outside of therapy.
Challenges of Dual Relationships
A dual relationship occurs when a therapist and client engage in a personal or social relationship outside of therapy, which can blur the boundaries of the therapeutic alliance. Dual relationships can create conflicts of interest, compromise the therapist’s objectivity, and potentially harm the client.
Some examples of dual relationships include socializing, business partnerships, or romantic relationships between a therapist and client. Mental health professionals are trained to avoid dual relationships and maintain a professional relationship with their clients.
Transference and Countertransference
Transference is a phenomenon where a client redirects their feelings or attitudes towards important figures from their past onto their therapist. A client who has issues with their caregivers may begin to see their therapist as a mother or father figure. Negative feelings about a friend may cause a client to lash out at their therapist. Or the therapist may remind them of an ex they have strong feelings for and cause romantic feelings.
Countertransference is when a therapist’s own feelings or attitudes towards the client influence their therapeutic approach. Understanding transference and countertransference is crucial for therapists to maintain a professional relationship and avoid dual relationships. Ethical guidelines establish a hard and fast rule against a relationship with your therapist, and breaking this may lead to a therapist losing their license or causing issues with their professional organizations.
These same emotional dynamics that influence ethical rules in place during therapy can also impact the possibility of forming a friendship with an ex therapist.
Understanding the Emotional Dynamics of a Therapy Relationship
The therapeutic relationship is built on unconditional positive regard, empathy, and genuineness, which can create strong emotional bonds between the therapist and client. However, these emotional dynamics can also make it challenging to transition from a therapeutic alliance to a friendship. Therapists must be aware of their own emotions and boundaries to maintain a professional and therapeutic alliance, and avoid problematic relationships.
Power Dynamics and Boundaries
The therapeutic relationship is inherently unequal, with the therapist holding a position of power and authority. This power imbalance can make it difficult to form a friendship or personal relationship outside of therapy, as the client may struggle to establish a sense of equality.
Therapists must maintain clear boundaries and avoid exploiting their power or influence over the client. Establishing and maintaining these healthy boundaries is essential for a therapeutic alliance and can also impact the possibility of forming a friendship, even with former clients.
Considering a Friendship with an Ex Therapist
Becoming friends with a former therapist can be a complex and challenging process, and requires careful consideration of the power dynamics and boundaries. Most therapists would not consider a friendship or other relationship outside the therapy room, even with a former client.
It’s essential to evaluate whether a friendship is possible and healthy, given the unique circumstances of the therapeutic alliance. Former therapists may have different policies or guidelines regarding friendships with ex-clients, which should be discussed and respected.
In addition, clients should prioritize their own life and emotional well-being and consider whether a friendship with a former therapist aligns with their mental health goals. If they should need future treatment, becoming good friends with their therapist would preclude seeking it in that therapist's office.
Navigating the Possibilities of a Patient Therapist Relationship
If a client and former therapist decide to pursue a friendship, it’s essential to establish clear boundaries and guidelines. The friendship should be built on mutual respect, trust, and open communication, with a clear understanding of the power dynamics and boundaries.
It’s crucial to prioritize the client’s emotional well-being and avoid any actions that could compromise the therapeutic alliance or create a dual relationship. In fact, this should never be attempted with a current therapist. Even with an ex-therapist, it should be approached with great caution.
Navigating the possibilities of a friendship with a former therapist requires careful consideration, respect, and open communication.
Seeking Healthy Relationships Outside the Therapy Room in Brooklyn
The therapeutic relationship is a unique and intimate connection that requires careful consideration of boundaries and power dynamics.
Maintaining the Therapist Client Relationship in Brooklyn
While it may be possible to form a friendship with a former therapist, it’s essential to prioritize the client’s emotional well-being and respect the boundaries of the therapeutic alliance. Therapeutic work is important, and a therapist isn't just some other friend. If are seeking a relationship with your old therapist, it's more often than not a bad idea and it may be time to end therapy with them and find a new therapist.
At Williamsburg Therapy Group, our team of doctoral-level Brooklyn psychotherapists offer a number of evidence-based therapeutic approaches that can offer tools for building friendships and other relationships with those with equal power dynamics, while providing good therapy that respects the professional code.
Call today to speak to our client coordinator, who can find the right therapist to address any challenges to building friendships, and offer new skills to create healthy relationships. Close friendships are important, and sometimes we seek therapists to fulfill this role and endanger the therapist client relationship. Most relationships built on this kind of foundation don't work and a good therapist will avoid this breach of ethical codes.
Williamsburg Therapy Group
